Poġġejna l-Huawei Mate 60 Pro+ permezz tas-suite rigoruża tagħna tat-test SBMARK Audio biex tkejjel il-prestazzjoni tiegħu kemm fir-reġistrazzjoni tal-awdjo bl-użu tal-mikrofoni integrati kif ukoll fid-daqq tal-awdjo permezz tal-kelliema.
F'din ir-reviżjoni, aħna ser nkissru kif wettaq f'varjetà ta 'testijiet u diversi każijiet ta' użu komuni.
Ħarsa ġenerali
L-ispeċifikazzjonijiet ewlenin tal-awdjo jinkludu:
- Żewġ kelliema (qiegħ il-lemin, fuq ix-xellug)
- Ebda output awdjo jack
Daqq
Prosperità
- Ton stramb, pjaċevoli bil-biċċa l-kbira tal-kontenut awdjo
- Pjuttost inċiżiv
Kontra
- Nuqqas qawwi ta' koerenza, wisq enfasi fuq l-ipproċessar diġitali
- Prestazzjoni fqira tal-artifact
Reġistrazzjoni
Prosperità
- Funzjonalità eċċellenti taż-żum tal-awdjo
- Prestazzjoni eċċellenti f'termini ta 'ħoss tar-riħ
- Bilanċ tonali tajjeb ħafna, speċjalment meta tuża l-kamera selfie
Kontra
- Reġistrazzjonijiet tal-kunċerti kompromessi minn bass boomy u midrange inkonsistenti
- Kompressjoni pjuttost qawwija meta tirrekordja kunċerti
With an overall SBMARK Audio score of 138, the Huawei Mate 60 Pro+ delivered a very decent performance even though it was outperformed by other devices in the Ultra Premium segment. In our tests, we found that both playback and recording are strongly influenced by digital signal processing (DSP), which brought some positive aspects, such as very effective audio zoom and wind noise reduction, as well as good signal-to-noise ratio, but the DSP also caused some problems, including compression, exaggerated fake bass, and other artifacts. Overall, the device offers a very pleasant tone in both playback and recording, but would definitely benefit from more consistent processing.
Playback performance in terms of timbre was best when watching movies, followed by gaming and then music. Results tended to vary greatly based on tonal content. In recording, the Huawei’s timbre and envelope were better with the main camera, compared to the selfie and memo use cases. Spatial performance, however, showed some disparity in results, with a narrow soundstage during selfie videos, but a good sense of directivity when using the Memo app.
Sommarju tat-test
Dwar it-testijiet tal-awdjo SBMARK: Għall-punteġġ u l-analiżi fir-reviżjonijiet tal-awdjo tal-ismartphone tagħna, l-inġiniera SBMARK iwettqu serje ta 'testijiet oġġettivi u jagħmlu aktar minn 20 siegħa ta' evalwazzjoni perċettiv taħt kundizzjonijiet tal-laboratorju kkontrollati.
(Għal aktar dettalji dwar il-protokoll ta’ daqq tagħna, ikklikkja hawn; għal aktar dettalji dwar il-protokoll ta’ reġistrazzjoni tagħna, ikklikkja hawn.)
It-taqsima li ġejja tiġbor flimkien elementi ewlenin tal-ittestjar u l-analiżi komprensivi tagħna mwettqa fil-laboratorji SBMARK. Evalwazzjonijiet dettaljati tal-prestazzjoni fil-forma ta' rapporti huma disponibbli fuq talba. Toqgħodx lura milli tikkuntattjana.
Kif huwa magħmul il-punteġġ tal-plejbek tal-awdjo
L-inġiniera ta’ SBMARK jittestjaw id-daqq permezz ta’ kelliema tal-ismartphone, li l-prestazzjoni tagħhom tiġi evalwata fil-laboratorji tagħna u f’kundizzjonijiet tal-ħajja reali, bl-użu ta’ apps u settings awtomatiċi.
In our tests, the Mate 60 Pro+ delivered an overall pleasant, colorful and vivid tone. That said, the device appeared to apply a lot of digital signal processing (DSP), which resulted in a lack of consistency across use cases and different types of audio content. The ratio between treble, midrange and bass was generally good, but bass performance was particularly affected by the DSP, resulting in an unnatural feel and boxy sound. While the midrange sounded warm and quite pleasant, the highs were once again affected by the DSP. It was very bright and could play resonant.
The DSP had a particularly detrimental impact on dynamics, resulting in inferior results compared to some of the Mate’s competitors in this category. While attack was average, bass precision left room for improvement, especially when listening to music. Punch was consistently good across all test use cases. The device provided good stereo width, but the localizability of individual sound sources was slightly confusing, again due to the behavior of the DSP. While distance rendering was satisfactory, depth rendering was less good, with little to no perceived separation between the different instruments.
Volume was good at maximum volume and well-tuned at the minimum volume setting. The distribution of volume levels was also quite consistent. While our testers didn’t notice any particularly noticeable artifacts, the sum of the issues resulted in a below-average score for this category. The volume may fluctuate and sometimes there is some compression. Resonances were problematic at nominal and low volumes, and during gaming, a natural hand position could easily occlude the right speaker, muting it completely.
Isma 'l-prestazzjoni tal-plejbek tal-ismartphone ittestjat f'dan il-paragun ma' xi wħud mill-kompetituri tiegħu:
Reġistrazzjonijiet ta' smartphones li jdoqqu wħud mill-binarji tal-mużika tagħna f'60 LAeq f'ambjent anekoiku bl-użu ta' 2 mikrofoni f'konfigurazzjoni AB, f'30 ċm
Hawn kif il-Huawei Mate 60 Pro+ jaħdem f'każijiet ta' użu ta' daqq meta mqabbel mal-kompetituri tiegħu:
Logħba ta' punteġġi ta' każi ta' użu
Il-punteġġ tat-Timbre jirrappreżenta l-kwalità li biha telefon jirriproduċi l-ħoss tul il-firxa tonali kollha li tinstema' u jqis id-dipendenza tal-bass, midrange, treble, tal-bilanċ tonali u tal-volum. Huwa l-aktar attribut importanti għar-riproduzzjoni.
Rispons tal-frekwenza tad-daqq tal-mużika
Grafika ta 'rispons tal-frekwenza ta' 1/12 ottava, li tkejjel il-qawwa ta 'kull output ta' frekwenza mill-ismartphone meta tilgħab mewġa sine pura f'ambjent anekoiku.
Il-punteġġ Dynamics ikejjel l-eżattezza tal-bidliet fil-livell tal-enerġija tas-sorsi tal-ħoss, bħal kemm tiġi riprodotta b'mod preċiż nota tal-baxx jew il-ħoss ta 'impatt ta' drum.
Attributi sekondarji ta 'testijiet spazjali jinkludu l-identifikazzjoni tal-post ta' ħoss speċifiku, il-bilanċ pożizzjonali tiegħu, id-distanza u l-amplitudni.
Il-punteġġ tal-volum jirrappreżenta l-volum ġenerali ta 'smartphone u kemm il-volum jiżdied u jonqos bla xkiel abbażi tal-input tal-utent.
Hawn huma xi livelli ta' pressjoni tal-ħoss (SPLs) imkejla meta nilqgħu r-reġistrazzjonijiet kampjuni tagħna ta' hip-hop u mużika klassika fil-volum massimu:
| hip hop | Classic | |
| Huawei Mate 60 Pro + | 74.9 dBA | 71.5 dBA |
| Apple iPhone 15 Pro Max | 75.1 dBA | 72.3 dBA |
| Huawei P60Pro | 71.9 dBA | 69.4 dBA |
Il-graff li ġej turi l-bidliet gradwali fil-volum li jmorru minn minimu għal massimu. Nistennew li dawn il-bidliet ikunu konsistenti fil-firxa kollha, sabiex iż-żidiet kollha fil-volum jaqblu mal-aspettattivi tal-utenti:
Konsistenza tal-volum tal-mużika
Din il-grafika tal-linja turi l-volum relattiv ta 'daqq kontra l-inkrement tal-volum magħżul mill-utent, imkejjel f'żidiet ta' volum differenti b'ħoss roża korrelatat f'kaxxa anekoika rreġistrata fuq l-assi f'0.20 metri.
Il-punteġġ Artifacts ikejjel il-punt sa fejn il-ħoss huwa affettwat minn diversi tipi ta 'distorsjoni. Aktar ma jkun għoli l-punteġġ, inqas ikun notevoli d-disturbi tal-ħoss. Jistgħu jseħħu distorsjonijiet minħabba l-ipproċessar tal-ħoss fl-apparat u l-kwalità tal-kelliema.
Distorsjoni armonika totali waqt il-daqq (volum massimu)
Din il-grafika turi distorsjoni armonika totali u storbju fil-medda ta 'frekwenza li tinstema'.
Jirrappreżenta d-distorsjoni u l-istorbju tal-apparat li qed jilgħab is-sinjal tat-test tagħna (0 dB Fs, Sweep Sine f'kaxxa anekoika f'40 ċm) fil-volum massimu tal-apparat.
Kif huwa magħmul il-punteġġ tar-reġistrazzjoni tal-awdjo
L-inġiniera ta 'SBMARK jittestjaw ir-reġistrazzjoni billi jevalwaw fajls irreġistrati fuq tagħmir awdjo ta' referenza. Dawn ir-reġistrazzjonijiet isiru fil-laboratorji tagħna u f'kundizzjonijiet tal-ħajja reali, bl-użu ta 'apps u settings default.
The timbre of the recording was quite natural with the main camera and the highs were quite clear. The midrange slightly lacked upper-mid clarity, but the body remained natural. Tonal balance was very good when using the selfie camera, with natural mids and highs being slightly brighter than on the main camera. Treble was also good when recording with the Memo app. The signal-to-noise ratio was very good with both the main and selfie cameras, background noise could have been attenuated more with the memo app, especially in urban scenarios. However, the enclosure was clear enough for voices to be perfectly intelligible.
The breadth of the recorded soundstage was very good with the main camera and recorder apps, but much more limited when recording selfie videos. Locability was accurate across all apps and cameras. Distance rendering was also accurate, especially with the selfie camera. Recordings were quite noisy when using the main and selfie cameras, but slightly softer with the memo app. Our testers found that recording artifacts were well under control, but there was strong compression when recording at high sound pressure levels, such as at concerts. The device’s microphones were also quite sensitive to occlusions. The rendering of the background was always excellent and free of artifacts. But our testers found it to sound slightly boomy in urban conditions.
Hawn kif il-Huawei Mate 60 Pro+ jaħdem fir-reġistrazzjoni ta’ każijiet ta’ użu meta mqabbel mal-kompetituri tiegħu:
Ir-reġistrazzjoni ta' punteġġi ta' każi ta' użu
Il-punteġġ tat-Timbre jirrappreżenta kemm telefon jaqbad ħsejjes fil-firxa tonali li tinstema' u jqis il-bass, il-mids, it-treble u l-bilanċ tonali. Huwa l-aktar attribut importanti għar-reġistrazzjoni.
Reazzjoni tal-frekwenza tal-vidjo tal-ħajja
Grafika tar-rispons tal-frekwenza ta '1/12 ottava, li tkejjel il-qawwa ta' kull frekwenza maqbuda mill-smartphone waqt li tirreġistra mewġa sine pura f'ambjent anekoiku.
Il-punteġġ tad-Dynamics ikejjel l-eżattezza tal-bidliet fil-livell tal-enerġija tas-sorsi tal-ħoss, bħal kemm huma riprodotti b'mod preċiż il-plożivi tal-vuċi (p, tek, per eżempju). Il-punteġġ iqis ukoll il-proporzjon tas-sinjal għall-istorbju (SNR), bħal kemm il-vuċi prinċipali hija qawwija meta mqabbla mal-istorbju fl-isfond.
Attributi sekondarji għall-ittestjar spazjali jinkludu l-identifikazzjoni tal-post ta 'ħoss speċifiku, il-bilanċ pożizzjonali tiegħu, id-distanza, u l-amplitudni fuq fajls awdjo rreġistrati.
Direttiva ta' reġistrazzjoni
Grafika tad-direttività tal-ismartphone waqt ir-reġistrazzjoni tas-sinjali tat-test bl-użu tal-app tal-kamera, bil-kamera prinċipali. Jirrappreżenta l-enerġija akustika (f'dB) meta mqabbla mal-angolu tal-inċidenza tas-sors tal-ħoss. (Normalizzat għall-angolu ta '0 °, quddiem l-apparat.)
Il-punteġġ tal-loudness jirrappreżenta kemm l-awdjo fuq il-fajls irreġistrati huwa normalizzat u kemm l-apparat jimmaniġġa tajjeb ambjenti storbjużi, bħal kunċerti elettroniċi, waqt ir-reġistrazzjoni.
Hawn huma l-livelli tal-ħoss irreġistrati fil-fajls tal-awdjo u tal-vidjo, imkejla f'LUFS (Loudness Unit Full Scale); Bħala referenza, nistennew li l-livelli tal-volum ikunu ogħla minn -24 LUFS għall-kontenut irreġistrat:
| Laqgħa | Vidjows dwar il-ħajja | Selfie videos | Memorandum | |
| Huawei Mate 60 Pro + | -25.4 LUFS | -20.2 LUFS | -18.9 LUFS | -21.4 LUFS |
| Apple iPhone 15 Pro Max | -24.9 LUFS | -22.1 LUFS | -20.5 LUFS | -19.2 LUFS |
| Huawei P60Pro | -24.5 LUFS | -19.4 LUFS | -18.9 LUFS | -20.2 LUFS |
Il-punteġġ Artifacts ikejjel sa liema punt il-ħsejjes irreġistrati huma affettwati minn diversi tipi ta 'distorsjonijiet. Aktar ma jkun għoli l-punteġġ, inqas ikun notevoli d-disturbi tal-ħoss. Jistgħu jseħħu distorsjonijiet minħabba l-ipproċessar tal-ħoss fl-apparat u l-kwalità tal-mikrofoni, kif ukoll l-immaniġġjar tal-utent, bħal kif jinżamm it-telefon.
F'dan il-paragun tal-awdjo tista' tisma' kif dan l-ismartphone jimmaniġġja l-istorbju tar-riħ meta mqabbel mal-kompetituri tiegħu:
matriċi (3) {
[“Huawei Mate 60 Pro +”] => string(72) “riżorsi/Huawei/Mate60Pro+V2.2/HuaweiMate60Pro+_MicrophoneArtifacts.m4a”
[“Apple iPhone 15 Pro Max”] => string(75) “riżorsi/Huawei/Mate60Pro+V2.2/AppleiPhone15ProMax_MicrophoneArtifacts.m4a”
[“Huawei P60 Pro”] => string(68) “riżorsi/Huawei/Mate60Pro+V2.2/HuaweiP60Pro_MicrophoneArtifacts.m4a” }
Reġistrazzjonijiet ta' kampjun ta' diskors b'ħoss fl-isfond ħafif, espost għal riħ turbulenti ta' 5 m/s
L-isfond jevalwa kif naturalment id-diversi ħsejjes madwar vuċi jingħaqdu flimkien fil-fajl tar-reġistrazzjoni tal-vidjo. Pereżempju, meta tirreġistra diskors f'avveniment, l-isfond m'għandux jinterferixxi mal-vuċi prinċipali, iżda għandu jipprovdi kuntest għall-ambjent tal-madwar.
Ibda Thread ġdid